Pep's Legit Pepperoni
Back to frozen pizzas

Pep's Pizza Co.

Pep's Legit Pepperoni

Thin Crust• $6-$8• 12 in
Yo Slice Score:7.8
Would Buy AgainBest for: Quick dinner, game day, Wisconsin nostalgia

Allergen Information

No special dietary designations

Contains:

WheatMilkSoy

Additional Allergen Notes:

Contains wheat, milk, and soy. No artificial flavors.

Ingredient Transparency:

Ingredients listed clearly on packaging. Made with Wisconsin cheese.

Allergen information is based on what's publicly available at time of review. Always check the product packaging for the most current information.

The Review

Pep's Legit lives up to its name — this is a legitimately good frozen pizza. The crust bakes up thin and crisp with a satisfying snap, the sauce has a tangy brightness that cuts through the cheese, and the pepperoni is laid on generously. What sets Pep's apart is the cheese quality — you can taste the Wisconsin mozzarella. It's not trying to be gourmet; it's trying to be the best frozen pizza in your freezer, and it makes a strong case. At $6-$8, it's one of the best values in the frozen aisle.

Score Breakdown

8.0

Crust

7.5

Sauce

8.0

Cheese

7.8

Taste

8.5

Value

🧬

Pizza DNA

Crust StyleThin
ThicknessThin
CrispnessCrisp
Sauce StyleTangy
Sauce SweetnessBalanced
Sauce AmountBalanced
Cheese QualityWhole milk mozzarella
Cheese CoverageEdge-to-edge
Topping GenerosityGenerous
Bake LevelGolden
Reheat QualityGood

Where to Buy

Festival Foods, Woodman's, and select Wisconsin grocery stores

About This Pizza

A Wisconsin-made frozen pizza with a signature thin crust, zesty sauce, and generous pepperoni. Made in Pep's La Crosse-area kitchens.