Find Your
Perfect Pizza
Discover pizza based on crust, sauce, sausage, atmosphere, allergy accommodations, family experience, drinks, patios, and hundreds of unique pizza characteristics.
Featured Critique
The Latest from Yo Slice
Ohio Street Pizza King
The Measuring Stick
10.0Ohio Street Pizza King is your small town family pizza shop that carries a strong tradition, exceptional balanced sauce, and a healthy covering of pizza toppings. The sausage is top tier. The pizza is affordable. For me it's a clear 10/10!
9.5
Crust
9.7
Sauce
9.5
Sausage
Tell us
Your Story
Your story powers your pizza! Let us help you tell it.
Browse Experiences
What Are You Craving?
Don't search by name. Search by what you're in the mood for.
Wisconsin Rankings
The Best Pizza, Ranked
The top 50 pizzas across Wisconsin, organized by what matters most to pizza lovers.
Latest Critiques
Fresh from the Editor
10.0Ohio Street Pizza King
The Measuring Stick
Ohio Street Pizza King is your small town family pizza shop that carries a strong tradition, exceptional balanced sauce, and a healthy covering of pizza toppings. The sausage is top tier. The pizza is affordable. For me it's a clear 10/10!
Read More
8.0Eaton's
A Contender with Room to Climb
Eaton's is absolutely a contender. A very good pizza.
Read More
9.0Polito's
The Underrated Pizza Conversation
Good sauce. Excellent sausage. Their sausage may actually be tied for first place. The best lunch special value in town.
Read More
9.0Christiano's
Worth Every Penny
A trip to Christianos might cost you an arm, but every once in a while it's worth every penny. The atmosphere is great, the pizza is consistently excellent.
Read More
8.7Stuc's
The Sweet Sauce Debate
Stuc's is controversial. San Marzano tomatoes create a sweeter, more authentic Italian-style sauce. Some people hate it. Some people love it. I'm firmly in the love it category.
Read More
9.5Cocoon Brewing
The Pizza I Legitimately Crave
This is a pizza I legitimately crave. Their spicy sausage pizza is one of the best pizzas I've had anywhere in Wisconsin.
Read MoreInteractive Pizza Map
Explore Pizza
Across the Midwest
Pan, zoom, and discover pizza restaurants across Wisconsin, Illinois, Minnesota, Michigan, Ohio, and beyond. Filter by what you crave and find your next slice.
Explore the Pizza MapPizza Stories
Share Your Story
Be the first to share a pizza experience with the community!
Grocery Aisle
Frozen Pizza Picks
Expert reviews of frozen pizzas — crust, sauce, allergens, and more.
Restaurant Spotlight
A Story Worth Telling
Ohio Street Pizza King
Oshkosh, WI
Around that same time, someone at UW Oshkosh who also worked at Pizza King on Ohio Street kept telling me, over and over, that they had the best pizza in town. After hearing it enough times, I finally gave it a shot. Turns out she wasn't wrong. I may be one of their better free marketing voices. In my opinion, Ohio Street Pizza King isn't just better than Cranky's...it was twice as good. The crust. The sauce. The sausage. The price. The family atmosphere. Their story. The care they put into every pizza. For me, it's a 10/10. Ohio Street gives you the right amount of toppings. They are simply more generous, more consistent, and more satisfying. The crust has more depth — it's thicker without being heavy. The high heat creates a slight flake and crunch while still allowing you to bite through it cleanly and get some depth to it.