The Critiques
Professional Editorial Reviews
Every critique follows the Yo Slice Standard. Written by our editors. Never influenced.
10.0Ohio Street Pizza King
The Measuring Stick
Ohio Street Pizza King is your small town family pizza shop that carries a strong tradition, exceptional balanced sauce, and a healthy covering of pizza toppings. The sausage is top tier. The pizza is affordable. For me it's a clear 10/10!
Read Full Critique
8.0Eaton's
A Contender with Room to Climb
Eaton's is absolutely a contender. A very good pizza.
Read Full Critique
9.0Polito's
The Underrated Pizza Conversation
Good sauce. Excellent sausage. Their sausage may actually be tied for first place. The best lunch special value in town.
Read Full Critique
9.0Christiano's
Worth Every Penny
A trip to Christianos might cost you an arm, but every once in a while it's worth every penny. The atmosphere is great, the pizza is consistently excellent.
Read Full Critique
8.7Stuc's
The Sweet Sauce Debate
Stuc's is controversial. San Marzano tomatoes create a sweeter, more authentic Italian-style sauce. Some people hate it. Some people love it. I'm firmly in the love it category.
Read Full Critique
9.5Cocoon Brewing
The Pizza I Legitimately Crave
This is a pizza I legitimately crave. Their spicy sausage pizza is one of the best pizzas I've had anywhere in Wisconsin.
Read Full Critique
9.0Gallagher's
The Reminder
It's the kind of pizza that reminds me why I keep ordering sausage and pepperoni whenever I try a new place. Great crust, cooked perfectly, balanced cheese, savory balanced sauce, and a generous amount of toppings.
Read Full Critique
8.0Sammy's
Nostalgia takes this to a top level pizza.
Generations of family memories make this pizza some of the be
Read Full Critique
7.0Murdock Street Pizza King
The Comparison
The sauce is the same or very close. But the difference is in the execution. Ohio Street is simply more generous, more consistent, and more satisfying.
Read Full Critique
7.5Fox River Brewing
The Crust Changed Everything
Their sauce was outstanding. Their sausage was excellent. Their Thai Pizza was one of the most unique pizzas in town. Then they changed the crust.
Read Full Critique