Pep Rally
Back to frozen pizzas

Pothole Pizza

Pep Rally

Thin Crust• $9-$10• 14 in
Yo Slice Score:8.3
Would Buy AgainBest for: Classic pepperoni, thin crust lovers, quick dinner

Allergen Information

No special dietary designations

Contains:

WheatMilkSoy

Additional Allergen Notes:

Contains wheat, milk, and soy.

Ingredient Transparency:

Made fresh in Kwik Trip's La Crosse kitchens.

Allergen information is based on what's publicly available at time of review. Always check the product packaging for the most current information.

The Review

The pepperoni Pothole is the one that started the cult following. Same cracker-thin crust, same sweet sauce, loaded with pepperoni. It's simple, it's classic, and it executes flawlessly. The pepperoni crisps up nicely in the oven, the cheese is solid Wisconsin mozzarella, and the sauce is the star — sweet, flavorful, and noticeably better than any national brand. At $9-$10 it's not cheap for a gas station pizza, but it outperforms most grocery store frozen pizzas by a wide margin.

Score Breakdown

8.5

Crust

8.8

Sauce

8.0

Cheese

8.5

Taste

7.5

Value

🧬

Pizza DNA

Crust StyleThin
ThicknessCracker-thin
CrispnessCracker-crisp
Sauce StyleSweet
Sauce SweetnessSweet
Sauce AmountBalanced
Cheese QualityWisconsin mozzarella
Cheese CoverageEdge-to-edge
Topping GenerosityGenerous
Bake LevelGolden
Reheat QualityBest fresh

Where to Buy

Kwik Trip and Kwik Star convenience stores (WI, MN, IA, IL, MI)

About This Pizza

The classic Pothole Pizza with a cracker-thin crust, sweet sauce, and pepperoni. A Wisconsin convenience store legend.