Stuc's

A very close second is Stuc's. Now, Stuc's is controversial. Their sauce uses San Marzano tomatoes, which creates a sweeter, more authentic Italian-style sauce. Some people hate it. Some people love it. I'm firmly in the "love it" category. It's similar to the Captain Crunch Chicken debate at Fox River Brewing. People either think it's genius or they think it's weird. There isn't much middle ground. The sweeter sauce at Stuc's is absolutely my jam. Stuc's earns its spot in the BEST tier. It's a close second to Christiano's in Appleton, and the sweet San Marzano sauce is what makes it special. If you're someone who appreciates an authentic Italian-style sweet sauce, this is your spot. If you're not...well, more for the rest of us.